Gloria Grandolini  


Untitled by Gloria Grandolini

November 2026 - Untitled

November 2026 - Gloria Grandolini

Original

About the Image(s)

Japanese Melon Learning Experience

Last week at the end of an Omakase dinner we were offered a small piece of a Japanese Muskmelon.
These delicious melons are revered in Japan as luxury foods and gifts. Once again I was mesmerized by the distinctive netted ring texture. The intricate webbing occurs naturally during cultivation. As the melon inside grows quickly the outer skin splits. The plant heals the cracks by exuding suberin, which I learnt solidifies into a raised, cork-like network pattern. This is what I wanted to focus on in my macro image.
I am presenting two images so you can maybe help me figure out why the iphone one (#1) appears better at achieving the depth objective than the Canon R5 with the 100 mm macro lens using focus stacking and then Helicon focus (#2). I took the image standing above the piece of melon in both cases.
The Canon image has more detail but flattens the melon rinds. I took it with manual focus and 1.4 magnification. I did in camera focus stacking of 30 images and then processed it with Helicon focus (Method B, Radius 13, and Smoothing 7). I used a tripod at 0.5 sec at f/11 (tried f/8 same results) and ISO100.
The one taken with the iphone is softer but has the depth and almost 3D feeling I was looking for!
So am I losing the depth because the focus-staking at high magnification is making everything uniformly sharp? And how could I fix it? Thank you!!!

Main Image: iPhone Pro Max 17

Original 1: Canon R5 with 100m macro lens focus-stacking 30 images



6 comments posted




Stuart Ord   Stuart Ord
Interesting!

I notice there's a significant difference in colour. I don't know if you took in RAW and processed them, or took the jpgs from the camera/phone, but they have been processed differently in that respect. I guess you know that Helicon can take RAW files from the bracket and produce a result in DNG. And I guess your iPhone can save in RAW, too.

But I suspect the answer is a combination of two other differences:
1. The focal lengths. The phone focal length, I suspect, is much less than the camera's, and so the perspective has changed. This, I think, is the key difference, it was physically closer to the melon.
2. The magnification. The phone's magnification is higher (assuming these pictures are the result of the full frames) and so even closer relative to the Canon.

I think you are at the peak of resolution and sharpness with your Canon set-up. There's no way a phone can presently match it optically, but because of the internal processing (and phones, I think, won't reveal what they did) they do do a super job.

You could blur the Canon's image selectively in post to get the sense of depth you wanted, or only stack the upper fraction of your bracket of images. Trial and error!
  Posted: 11/09/2026 10:58:01
Gloria Grandolini   Gloria Grandolini
Thank you Stuart very useful comments and tip. I have to keep testing.   Posted: 11/11/2026 21:50:34



Margaret West   Margaret West
I think the Canon has a lot of depth too the colors are different. I bet the phone photo would not hold up enlarged. Usually they start to look pixelated even when the phone is in RAW. Both are nice. The Tony Kyper plug in has a way to adjust depth like Stuart is talking about so less trial and error. I don't use that part of the plug-in since I usually try to get the depth I want in camera.   Posted: 11/09/2026 14:45:45
Gloria Grandolini   Gloria Grandolini
Thanks Margaret very useful, and yes once enlarged the iphone cannot compete.   Posted: 11/11/2026 21:52:01



Jeff Fleisher   Jeff Fleisher
I would agree with both Margaret and Stuart. 3-D is created by shadows and lighting and the two images are vastly different in that respect. The lighting in the image labeled original is much flatter and it has lost almost all the color renditions which would give it some depth.

It is a very interesting subject. I think I will look at the produce department differently the next time I go shopping!   Posted: 11/17/2026 15:36:56



Carol Sheppard   Carol Sheppard
So different from each other! The one which shows as your main image looks sharper to me, with rich colors. I'm sorry I can't keep straight which is which! If both are RAW, I would surmise that the iPhone still does a bit of "in-camera processing. And although I agree that enlarged iPhone photos are noisy/pixelated, I still think on first look they always seem to look better than the DSLR or mirrorless images. That's one reason I default to my IPhone for most of my travel photos. Not wildlife and not some other stuff, but 90% of my travel images. I don't print or enlarge much anymore.   Posted: 11/18/2026 19:04:43



 

Please log in to post a comment