Peter Hornbostel, MPSA/2
About the Image(s)
This is a picture from my trip in Southern Germany to a sea named Federsee. Lots of birds (last one shown was a bearded reedling) - phantastic. This swan was always surrounded by dirt or other disturbing things in the water. I waited a long time to catch him in clear water. This one is only developped with camera raw, nothing else. OCC!
Canon R5 with Canon 200-800mm; Ap. 9.0; shutterspeed 1/1000, ISO 3200 by 432 mm. Freehand.
3 comments posted
Peter - Elegance, symmetry, and a touch of Mother Nature's artistry - you've combined all three in a photograph that invites the viewer to slow down and simply enjoy the scene.
The raised wings, graceful curve of the neck, and wonderful reflection create a lovely sense of tranquility.
I particularly like the simplicity of your composition and the soft blue water, which provides excellent contrast to the swan's white plumage. The reflection is especially effective because it becomes an integral part of the composition rather than simply a duplicate of the subject.
My principal suggestion concerns the lighting. The swan's head and neck are considerably darker than its body, and because our eyes naturally gravitate toward the brightest part of an image, the wings tend to compete with the head for attention. I think selectively brightening the head and neck would improve the visual hierarchy and create better tonal balance.
What appeals to me most is that you've taken an ordinary scene and transformed it into something artistic. It's a great example of how simplicity, reflection, and thoughtful composition can produce a photograph with considerable visual interest. Nicely done!
  Posted: 11/03/2026 16:25:05
The raised wings, graceful curve of the neck, and wonderful reflection create a lovely sense of tranquility.
I particularly like the simplicity of your composition and the soft blue water, which provides excellent contrast to the swan's white plumage. The reflection is especially effective because it becomes an integral part of the composition rather than simply a duplicate of the subject.
My principal suggestion concerns the lighting. The swan's head and neck are considerably darker than its body, and because our eyes naturally gravitate toward the brightest part of an image, the wings tend to compete with the head for attention. I think selectively brightening the head and neck would improve the visual hierarchy and create better tonal balance.
What appeals to me most is that you've taken an ordinary scene and transformed it into something artistic. It's a great example of how simplicity, reflection, and thoughtful composition can produce a photograph with considerable visual interest. Nicely done!
  Posted: 11/03/2026 16:25:05
Thank you, Butch! You are right, the head and neck are darker. I have seen other swans on this sea - same effect. If this is a result of searching food in the water? I don't know. Of course you can try to lighten up this brown/yellow part, but it would not get white like the rest of the body. I will see, how it looks like. And, you know, I can use it then only in "Open Color" and no more in "Nature" (always the same, ha!)   Posted: 11/04/2026 06:25:27
You have beautifully handled the swan in this picture. The whites are not blown out, but they are bright as expected. The neck being darker does not bother me, as I expect this from Swans, but understand others may expect this to be white. The reflection is handled well and adds to the image. The blue of the sky reflection and the orange of the beak really compliment each other. A well done image!   Posted: 11/04/2026 16:41:47
