Pinaki Sarkar
About the Image(s)
Technical : ISO 900, F11, 1/100 , 100 mm, Processed through Lightroom
Background : Shot in October at a Local Wood
7 comments posted
Pinaki, it has nice colors but lacks a center of interest. The branch of yellow leaves on the left don't add to the picture and I suggest you crop them out. Also, I find the bright areas on the top are distracting.   Posted: 11/06/2026 19:13:29
Fall is my favorite season and I always like to see the colors appear. I like the softness of the background in this... I'm surprised by the relatively shallow depth of field at f/11... you must have been fairly close. It is hard to get a sense of scale here... The colors on the tree carry the most visual weight and where I first look. But my eye wonders after that. I'm curious what kind of tree it is but can't really figure it.   Posted: 11/11/2026 21:24:10
Hi Pinaki,
I have to agree with Bil's suggestion to remove the blurred yellow leaves the left edge of the scene. Otherwise, I appreciate the sense of depth in your image.   Posted: 11/11/2026 23:35:39
I have to agree with Bil's suggestion to remove the blurred yellow leaves the left edge of the scene. Otherwise, I appreciate the sense of depth in your image.   Posted: 11/11/2026 23:35:39
Hi Pinaki. I think what is interesting here is the contrast between the golden leaves and the greens - both in the partial turning leaves, and the contrast with the background. I'd agree with others though that the brights at the top, and the bright yellow at the left edge is distracting. I think I'd prefer a tighter composition which gives a stronger sense of gesture in the subject leaves - something like what I've attached. Alternatively, I like the curved line of the top of the subject leaves and one could crop around that following it further to the right than what i've done in my crop.
  Posted: 11/20/2026 13:37:05
  Posted: 11/20/2026 13:37:05
I think with this crop the magic of the woods is Lost.   Posted: 11/20/2026 13:54:48
Fair enough. I'm curious what magic of the woods means to you? Perhaps knowing that I would suggest something different.   Posted: 11/20/2026 14:25:08
That's fine. A photo should be emotionally appealing. All responses are subjective. Thanks   Posted: 11/20/2026 14:58:22

