Charles Walker
March 2025 - Feral Mutt
Original
About the Image(s)
A couple years ago, I took a series of photographs inside the dilapidated Eastern State Penitentiary.
While recently reviewing them, the idea of inserting a living thing into this dead space occurred to me.
So, after doing a lot of cropping and filling in the open door, I inserted the image of a feral dog I
captured in 2016 in Havanna Cuba. For dramatic effect, all but the mutt was converted to black &
white. The image has a lot of texture and grain, which I feel adds to its emotional tone. What do you
think? Camera data: Nikon 7Zii, f/8, 1/20, 120mm, ISO=1600.
This round’s discussion is now closed!
5 comments posted
(Group 32)
Both shots are very interesting, but I believe they are different.
I like the original very much. I have a personal preference for architectural shots empty of human or animal life. In this original, the brightly lighted windows serve as focal points. I do not find the dog a success to do the same. Also, a bit too much contrast in the dog shot. I prefer the somber tones of the original. Posted: 03/04/2025 14:52:44
I like the original very much. I have a personal preference for architectural shots empty of human or animal life. In this original, the brightly lighted windows serve as focal points. I do not find the dog a success to do the same. Also, a bit too much contrast in the dog shot. I prefer the somber tones of the original. Posted: 03/04/2025 14:52:44
I agree. Another shot taken at Eastern State is more in compliance with your suggestions? Posted: 03/08/2025 18:20:20
Charles: Wonderful work. I like the addition of the dog; to me it represents life in a place of desolation and decay and immediately draws the eye in.
Mark Posted: 03/22/2025 18:59:14
Mark Posted: 03/22/2025 18:59:14
Brian Howard
Kudos on getting the lines mostly square in both the original photo and the followup to Stephen's comment. That is something I never really paid attention to until a training I did with PSA. Spot on!
The door and the dog change the mood of the photo for me. Something of hope or life versus the original being a feeling of despair. The follow up to Stephen's question I think adds to the feeling of despair as the photo is not centered.
Not something I normally think about - but I like where you are going with these! Posted: 03/23/2025 04:24:01
The door and the dog change the mood of the photo for me. Something of hope or life versus the original being a feeling of despair. The follow up to Stephen's question I think adds to the feeling of despair as the photo is not centered.
Not something I normally think about - but I like where you are going with these! Posted: 03/23/2025 04:24:01
Nice shot! The original image, with its outstanding top lighting, has a beautifully striking effect. Posted: 03/31/2025 16:45:07