Chan Garrett
About the Image(s)
I enjoy these simple home projects. Select some simple objects. Arrange them on a base placed on a table top, and use window light to illuminate the scene. Do basic processing in Lightroom Classic. Move to photoshop to remove the background and for dodging and burning. Open in Silver Effex pro. for B&W conversion and back to Photoshop to add a solid color layer. This time I decided to add a texture layer. Question, does the texture layer add to or subtract from the image?
15 comments posted
This is a fun still-life! I like the treatment but I think the texture makes it a bit busy and detracts from the composition; if I may suggest, consider the original image with a bit more contrast and a subtle vignette. Also, think about whether the frog belongs with the other items thematically?   Posted: 11/01/2026 18:37:20
Thanks to all of you who have responded. The group continues to work as intended. You continue to help me to improve my work.
As for the background texture edge, you all seem to agree that it is a distraction. I need your trained eyes to find out what works. The edge texture will be dropped.
As for the frog, it is what ties the serries together (my signature). Most of you agree that the frog can stay.
Thank you!   Posted: 11/04/2026 19:42:12
As for the background texture edge, you all seem to agree that it is a distraction. I need your trained eyes to find out what works. The edge texture will be dropped.
As for the frog, it is what ties the serries together (my signature). Most of you agree that the frog can stay.
Thank you!   Posted: 11/04/2026 19:42:12
I guess I did not notice the frog from prior images. Aplologies and agree.   Posted: 11/04/2026 20:34:10
So interesting. I'm assuming when you say texture, it is the white cloudy area around the image? To me, that makes it look like the entire project is floating in the clouds. I like the color you chose, not quite a sepia, but close. Everything is very sharp.   Posted: 11/03/2026 00:54:32
See my response to Will.   Posted: 11/04/2026 19:43:05
Chan - I admire your creativity with the things around you! The items and surface you staged are very interesting. Sharp image/lots of good detail to look at. Regarding the frog (that we've come to know/enjoy!) - I have mixed feelings. On one hand - he doesn't belong. On there other hand - his presence adds whimsy/playfulness which improves the image. Keep the frog. I also prefer the image without the large texture/border. To my eye - it's too big/busy and detracts from the image. I want to look at the subject - but my gaze keeps getting pulled to the border (which actually is interesting).   Posted: 11/04/2026 10:36:45
See my response to Will.   Posted: 11/04/2026 19:43:26
Hi Chan! An interesting still life - and I'm happy to see the frog again. It changes the photo from old-timey to playful. I'm undecided about the texture - it is interesting, but does make the whole thing very busy.   Posted: 11/04/2026 17:16:11
See my response to Will.   Posted: 11/04/2026 19:43:41
I think the texture layer is adding to the image. I'm not sure what your intention was, but it looks to me like the objects are floating in the air in the middle of a white cloud. If your intention was to create this surreal look (which goes well with the interesting objects on the table), then it's a good picture!   Posted: 11/04/2026 19:45:51
First, see my reply to Will.
I now agree that the background texture edge causes the main image to appear to be floating in a cloud. That is not my intent. My intend in this entire series of still life images is to simplify the canvas in order to allow the main image to be presented without any background elements to distract. Much like one would photograph an object on a white (or black, green, brown, etc.) background in a studio setting. The image that I include marked "Original" is the final before I decided to experiment with the texture edge.   Posted: 11/04/2026 20:01:47
I now agree that the background texture edge causes the main image to appear to be floating in a cloud. That is not my intent. My intend in this entire series of still life images is to simplify the canvas in order to allow the main image to be presented without any background elements to distract. Much like one would photograph an object on a white (or black, green, brown, etc.) background in a studio setting. The image that I include marked "Original" is the final before I decided to experiment with the texture edge.   Posted: 11/04/2026 20:01:47
I like texture blending a lot, so maybe I was more partial to it than some of the others in the group, but it all depends on what you were trying to convey. I think the texture adds an element of nostalgia, which goes along with the sepia toning and the nature of the objects. But if your goal is to simplify the canvas, then I agree that it would be better to omit it. I like that you made the frog your signature--that can provide some creative thinking with future images.   Posted: 11/04/2026 20:05:45
Thanks for your reply. I depend on this group for six other trained pair of eyes to critique my images.   Posted: 11/04/2026 20:09:11
The concept is there and with a few tweaks, as the group suggested, the photo could come around to be more refined. For whatever reason, the texture in the background i saw first. It reminds me of an old map. The texture did grab my attention enough for me to stop and look around.   Posted: 11/05/2026 01:12:24
Thanks, Dan. I appreciate your help with this image.   Posted: 11/05/2026 02:27:38

