John, absolutely a gorgeous image. Wouldn't change a thing. Perfect crop and excellent sharpness and detail. Outstanding!   Posted: 11/04/2025 14:13:15

I agree with Tom that you captured a beautiful image. My only suggestion for improvement is to address that white area between the trees in the middle of the photo. That bright area drew my eyes to it like a magnate. I think you can fix that problem by brushing those white patches and darkening them slight.   Posted: 11/04/2025 18:33:46

John, I think this is a sharp image capturing well the beautiful colors of the fall. However, I disagree with Tom and Mike regarding composition. I don't really know what this image is about. The green tree is cut, the reflections are nice but they got lost. The right side of the image is dark and flat and the left is bright with strong contrast. Sorry to be a voice out of the chorus but to me this image does not work.

best wishes

Michele   Posted: 11/04/2025 19:46:49