Larry Treadwell  


How is this possible? by Larry Treadwell

November 2026 - How is this possible?

About the Image(s)

How is this possible?

Camera Nikon D700 (full frame) with Nikkor 200-400mm f4 lens, ISO 400, f4, 1/800, camera was hand held.
This image was taken in Rocky Mountain National Park in the meadow just after the passing through the Fall River entry point, in late May of 2014. I first spotted the two sparing young elks in a meadow and jumped out of my car to capture the action. I was so caught up in the action I didn’t notice until later the “tiny” elk walking on the left side of this frame. There was no miniature elk walking in the meadow that morning. The two sparing elk are clearly further away from the camera position than the tiny elk passing by. The elk passing by seems to have a more mature body appearance but is still shown as being smaller. There is not Photoshop trick being played here, this is a single frame. So my question, and challenge to all you photo experts how is this image possible? What kind of freak camera action allowed this image to happen? In more than a decade since this was taken I’ve shown it to a number of people and no one has provided a satisfactory answer other than to accuse me of making this up and using Photoshop. I’m eager to hear your thoughts. I sent this image to Nikon long ago and never received a reply of any kind.


10 comments posted




Butch Mazzuca   Butch Mazzuca
Larry, what a fascinating image! First, congratulations on capturing a truly interesting moment of wildlife behavior. The interaction between the two sparring elk is terrific. The third elk? Well, that takes the image, as you described, beyond interesting and into the world of mystery!

I won't even attempt to explain this through perspective, the relative sizes of the animals, or the possibility that the sparring elk appear larger because they're rearing up on their hind legs. I've consulted Chat, who knows considerably more about camera optics and lens behavior than I do, and even Chat couldn't provide a definitive explanation. So, the mystery remains.

If it were me, I'd send the image back to Nikon and suggest that solving this little mystery might be a wonderful opportunity for some free publicity, particularly within the PSA community. After all, how often does a photograph raise a question that remains unanswered more than a decade later?
Whatever the explanation, you've captured something that goes beyond an interesting wildlife photograph.

Larry you've captured two stories: the obvious one involving the sparring elk, and the unexpected mystery of the third animal. Story is king in wildlife photography and your fighting ungulates is an excellent one, but it's the second story, the phantom third elk, that may be what makes the photograph memorable.

Very well-done, Larry
  Posted: 11/01/2026 15:32:13
Larry Treadwell   Larry Treadwell
Butch
I've love credit for this mystery, but on my part this is just plain old dumb luck! I have no idea what happened. It has bugged me for years.   Posted: 11/01/2026 22:08:06



Mariana Kruger   Mariana Kruger
Larry, a beautiful shot of these two fighting elks and of course the mystery passing elk.

What makes this unique is the perfect Depth of field to get all three in focus.

Spending as much time as I do outdoors and in nature, I usually joke that some animals grow wings to make sure they don't leave any visible spoor for us to follow and just magically appear somewhere else.

Animals are so good at becoming one with their environments, it is incredible.

The story behind this makes this photo unique, well done!

  Posted: 11/02/2026 06:52:31
Larry Treadwell   Larry Treadwell
This image does little for me other than that darn intruder who just drives me nuts. I've got better sparing photos. It is strange because I didn't notice him until after taking the shot. So maybe he has those wings you mention.   Posted: 11/18/2026 20:36:11



Ann Von Pentz   Ann Von Pentz
Hi Larry,
I commend you on this capture of sparring elk, something I've been chasing throughout the rut season, and your timing was impeccable! Both bulls rearing simultaneously--great capture!
The third elk and its mysterious size are intriguing. I wonder whether differences in the animals' ages and sizes, combined with perspective might contribute to the illusion? Fun to think about and it adds an interesting element to the story!
The harsh lighting and busy background are unfortunate, but you got the sparring shot and that is wonderful!
  Posted: 11/03/2026 15:23:40



Larry Treadwell   Larry Treadwell
Thanks for commenting Ann. I just o not know what to say. I've spoken the the grand council of the Elks (they have a Lodge near where I live) and explained to them that they should be be sparring when the light is harsh. I've explained about photography and the light and even suggested that sparring in harsh light might be detrimental to THEIR health---having the sun in their eyes could momentarily blind them and they could get speared by an antler. In spite of my thoughtful warnings they refuse to make any changes. I will admit that the Grand Elk seems more concerned with drinking his beer than listening to me. And would you believe the beer was not even Coors!!!   Posted: 11/03/2026 18:14:03



Cindy Marple   Cindy Marple
When I first looked at this before reading the narrative, I thought I was looking at 2 bulls sparring over a cow. Then I realized the "cow" has antlers. In looking closely at the antlers, they are different in shape between the bulls and the smaller animal. This leads me to suggest the 3rd animal is a Mule Deer buck, not an Elk. They're all in pretty shaggy coats and you can't see the ears very well, nor the rump, to be sure of this- but the size comparison fits with what I researched.
Back to the photo. What great timing to catch both of them reared up like this. It's a pleasant setting and the 3rd animal does invite stories!   Posted: 11/07/2026 23:22:26
Larry Treadwell   Larry Treadwell
Hi Cindy. The suggestion of the "visitor" being a mule deer is interesting. Never thought of that. I was really amazed at the size the antlers because is was so early in the spring. None of these guys have shed their winter coats as yet. The near by cows had all shed their coats.   Posted: 11/18/2026 20:41:26



David Kepley   David Kepley
Larry,
Sorry, I cannot explain the mystery either, but maybe we should just accept mystery when it happens! Great capture of the two sparing kids!   Posted: 11/14/2026 18:24:50



Larry Treadwell   Larry Treadwell
Thanks for the thought anyway. I guess this will always be a mystery. What will be will be...   Posted: 11/18/2026 20:43:25



 

Please log in to post a comment