Bob Wills  


Trek Trolls by Bob Wills

November 2026 - Trek Trolls

November 2026 - Bob Wills

Original

November 2026 - Bob Wills

Original 2

November 2026 - Bob Wills

Original 3

About the Image(s)

A busload of us “olde folks” climbed aboard a Patriots Landing bus for a trip to NW Trek in Pierce County to see the traveling troll exhibit by Danish artist Thomas Dambo. The exhibit features eight giant, multi-ton trolls tucked away along the park’s forested trails and throughout its natural habitats.

Dambo has created more than 172 trolls around the world, using recycled and reclaimed materials such as wood, pallets, and other locally sourced scraps. Many of these community-sponsored projects are built with help from local volunteers. We had more fun than work and thoroughly enjoyed the outing! I took lots of photographs and have already printed several to share with my neighbors. However, I haven't shown them this particular image yet.

I started with a new gray layer and added the elements to that layer. I considered using Smart Objects, but I really don't know enough about them yet, other than understanding that they're a non-destructive way of working. I also tried to improve the blending, but I don't think I've quite gotten the hang of that yet.

I made a point of saving my work along the way, only to lose all my layers when I flattened the image and closed the individual elements in Photoshop. That's when I discovered that saving doesn't necessarily mean saving everything the way you intended!
At this point, I think my brain is getting a little fried from trying to incorporate too many new processes at once. I may need to slow down and master a few techniques before adding more to the mix.

Dorinda isn't particularly fond of the effects I used, so I'll hold off on showing it around until I hear what you all think. As always, I'm looking forward to your honest opinions and some good suggestions on how I might improve it!


17 comments posted




Angela Bonner   Angela Bonner
I love the Trolls!! Must have made a great walk seeing all of them.
I think the images have been put together very well. I especially like having a group of "oldies" and some youngsters playing off to the side. You have chosen the right Troll as your main image as he seems to be looking at all of you. Not too sure what effect you have used but I like it and think it works well.
Well done.   Posted: 11/01/2026 17:39:24
Bob Wills   Bob Wills
Thanks, Angela. I forgot to add my processing last night, I used a couple of Artistic filters. Poster Edges and Underpainting at different opacities. I also used ACR as a filter to try to harmonize things, but I don't know...   Posted: 11/01/2026 17:51:28



Steve Wessing   Steve Wessing
The composition is fine. The elements fit well together. I don't lke the texture you've achieved. it imposes unnatural detail, while also losing contrast and actual definition. I think a misty gaussian effect would better match the subject.   Posted: 11/01/2026 18:00:41
Bob Wills   Bob Wills
Thanks, Steve. I couldn't find anything in PS that would create a rainy day, and wasn't satisfied with a gaussian blur only. I'm trying a paint job now. One never knows.   Posted: 11/01/2026 20:45:18
Comment Image
Steve Wessing   Steve Wessing
Better.   Posted: 11/02/2026 00:06:01
Bob Wills   Bob Wills
Perhaps the blur is already part of the original image, and adding more would be redundant. No need to make the aging eyes work any harder than necessary! : - D

  Posted: 11/02/2026 14:51:50



Sylvia Williams   Sylvia Williams
Hi Bob,
I love the composition. I thought it was one photo (not a composite) when I first looked at it. While I like it, I don't like the final texture as something I would hang on my wall.   Posted: 11/03/2026 22:18:48
Bob Wills   Bob Wills
Me either. Thanks Sylvia. Here is my next attempt. I got rid of the texture, and some of the blur. I'm putting this together for my pals the "olde folks" in this image, and our activity director. We'll see more Trolls at Pt Defiance Zoo next month.   Posted: 11/04/2026 15:41:28
Comment Image
Bob Wills   Bob Wills
I had to remove our driver from the image, and I put myself in her place next to dorinda. The tour PL coordinator doesn't allow driver photos in resident events.   Posted: 11/07/2026 21:43:36
Comment Image



Jan Handman   Jan Handman
What a great way to incorporate art into the natural environment! The trolls are totally endearing. I like your arrangement of the elements; the main troll is so cute and funny. I kind of would like to see his whole tush though, as in the original. Since his head is upside down, I think it might give a little more needed context.

My sympathies on losing your layers; I've done that once or twice myself! Once I get to a point where I'm ready to flatten, I save the version with all the layers, then save a copy and call it XX-flattened.tif. I open that copy and THEN flatten it. Once I have only one layer again (background), I duplicate the layer so I can experiment with filters and such but still have the flattened layer intact. The advantage to that is also that you can apply Poster Edges, for example, and reduce the opacity of that layer so it's less harsh over the top of the "background" layer. Sometimes I duplicate a layer for each filter I want to apply to build effects, but not lose the previous layers. Not sure I'm explaining this very clearly.

The Poster Edges filter is a favorite of mine, but it definitely doesn't work great on faces, so I usually completely or partially erase the effect there. I've also found that in order to keep things subtle, the Edge Thickness and Edge Intensity sliders work best at no more than 0 or 1, and Posterization all the way to the right.

This will be a fun and unique reminder of the outing you and your neighbors participated in. Great times!   Posted: 11/08/2026 00:12:48
Bob Wills   Bob Wills
Thank you, Jan. I'm not exactly sure why I "axed" his butt, but I can see the improvement if it's included!

I think I made the background layer (50% gray) at 1200 x 800 to meet the DD requirements. I probably should have made it larger to give myself more room to fit everything in. I've included a copy of what I've managed so far, but it's definitely taxing my brain to get it looking right. I tried starting over twice with the original elements, but kept running into dead ends.

Thanks for the sympathies and the workflow advice. I'm trying Poster Edges mostly because you've used it so successfully. Me, not so much! Maybe I'm trying to add too much too quickly. And Adobe keeps changing things with AI faster than I can learn them, making my workflow feel dated before I've even figured it all out!   Posted: 11/17/2026 00:49:38
Comment Image
Jan Handman   Jan Handman
The group of seniors is definitely highlighted in this version, but I kind of miss seeing the children at the same level. I do like the "whole tush" version.

Just curious...Why did you start with a gray background? Which of the three images did you open first in PS? One suggestion for making Poster Edges less harsh (and some other filters too): keep the original size of your starting image (usually the background) when you start post-processing. Sometimes mine are 3,000 or 4,000 pixels wide. When the filters get applied to a larger image, they have more pixels to spread themselves out over. Not exactly a scientific explanation, but that's how it seems to me. I don't reduce the size of my final image for DD requirements until the very last step.   Posted: 11/17/2026 18:34:53
Bob Wills   Bob Wills
Thanks, Jan. I started with a gray background from a tip I saw on a PS training which is better for adding shadows. I am using PS 2027 now and a lot has been fixed and more AI processing added. I opened the below image as the background. I use mostly Smart Objects for their ability to resize automatically as the image changes and also because it is non-destructive, so I am told. I start at 300 ppi, so the image is 1200x300 or 5000 pixels x shortest side which works as you state. This keeps the crop dimensions for DD. I have other size templates for printing, etc.
As far as the highlight, I am creating this image for my Activity Coordinator, not competition. She wanted us to be the stars, so we are.   Posted: 11/18/2026 15:49:31
Comment Image
Jan Handman   Jan Handman
I think you're developing a workflow that works really well for you. PS is such a multi-faceted program, and there are many different ways to get to the desired outcome. You're making big strides with your composites, for sure.   Posted: 11/18/2026 23:05:10
Bob Wills   Bob Wills
I'm afraid I'm more nerd than creative, but I'm trying. I appreciate everyone's help.   Posted: 11/19/2026 01:58:09



Leonie Lewis   Leonie Lewis
HI Bob
I think the composition of the three elements is fantastic and scaled well. Like others I don't think the filter you used does not work on the faces. I think this is a fun and whimsical image and scaled really well   Posted: 11/08/2026 02:24:13
Bob Wills   Bob Wills
Thank you, Leonie. I appreciate your feedback. I've since removed the filter, which really wasn't a good choice. I enjoy feedback, especially when it gives me new ideas for improving my images.   Posted: 11/15/2026 16:54:34



 

Please log in to post a comment