Very interesting different "levels" of reflections from the spacing of the trees. The bottom left reflection might be darkened down so that the eye is not pulled there. But I certainly would not want the left tree cropped out, as I think it gives the image contrast and a framing base. Similarly, you might consider darkening the water on the right edge to help with that framing, and balance with the top right.   Posted: 06/05/2022 10:24:28

Nice image! I agree with Bob on the darkening of the sides, maybe even an overall vignette, so your eye is drawn into the center. I am not quite sure about the left hand side tree though (it draws a lot of attention by having bright parts), but either darken it or crop it out entirely (5x4 image). See what you like most.   Posted: 06/07/2022 04:14:34

I find the image overall too green! I would decrease the saturation of the greens and maybe increase yellow to get some contrast. Darkening might help as Bob suggests.

The trees form good framing for the composition so I would definitely not remove either of them.   Posted: 06/08/2022 11:13:34

I find this almost confusing...in that there is no "horizon" or ground-level. I don't think that is necessarily bad though--it is an interesting effect. My only other comment is that there isn't really a subject--although the entire image is pleasant, there is nothing that talks to me as the subject of the image. Of course, not all images need a specific subject--but it usually helps if there is something, even something small, that would stand out a bit.   Posted: 06/09/2022 22:43:03

I like the mood of the image. Smooth and peaceful water surface has a calming effect. The colors look quite natural to me as well. I wonder if finding a vanishing point could further improve the composition.   Posted: 06/27/2022 10:55:59