Rick Cloran, HonPSA, MPSA  


Spokane Upper Falls by Rick Cloran, HonPSA, MPSA

October 2019 - Spokane Upper Falls

October 2019 - Rick Cloran, HonPSA, MPSA

Original

About the Image(s)

This one isn’t an exhibition image by any stretch but it proved to be a learning experience. The original bracket was made using a Canon 5D MK III and Sigma 24-105 ART based on five shots (one stop intervals) centered around a core exposure of 1/320 at F 11.3 iso 200. I made the first blend in Aurora 2019 and was very disappointed to see the extent of the highlight clipping. I tried doing the blend in Camera Raw but Photoshop refused to do it, possibly relating to the most recent update since it wouldn’t be the first time something like that happened. My solution was to process and pull in the minus 1 exposure and manually mask in the water from that image. The result wasn’t terrible, but it wasn’t what I was looking for either. I updated Photomatix to version 6.1 and gave that a run. The blend was better, but the blended image was very soft. I could (and did) fix most of that in Photoshop, but it continues to show that Photomatix’s alignment algorithms leave something t be desired. After mulling on it a bit, I went back into Aurora and did a blend on just three images, base exposure and plus 1 and minus 1. That result is the second image I’m sending along for this month. The water is different, but the blend was much cleaner. I would say that if you have a situation where the clipping in the plus 2 image is severe, don’t use it in Aurora unless you absolutely need it to handle the shadow details.


This round’s discussion is now closed!
5 comments posted




Max Burke   Max Burke
The image appears nicely done not realizing all the changes you attempted. Often slower water pleases many photographers, but the water is somewhere between soft and hard, as regards movement. Color is good and beings is has features from their World's fair, sort of detracts, but being straight with what you had looks well done to me.   Posted: 10/19/2019 21:53:06



Brad Ashbrook   Brad Ashbrook
I agree with you in regards to Aurora (new or old version), I try not to use a source file that is too bright, it makes the blend much more difficult. Water is also tough with HDR, it becomes a little too gritty with multiple softness versions.   Posted: 10/20/2019 16:33:32



 
Beautiful shot of nature. Nice colors and composition. Good blending and enough details allover the picture. I agree that shooting at slower speed may add to the water stream.   Posted: 10/25/2019 07:08:34



Lisa Cuchara   Lisa Cuchara
Thank you for the detailed description. That is one of the things I love most about DD, when people add details and what they did (and much better than FB and getting a "like").

The effort paid off, as the blend looks natural and the image does not have a tell tale HDR look.   Posted: 10/30/2019 00:57:43



Bill Buchanan   Bill Buchanan
Thanks for the detailed information. Your persistence paid off. I too have experienced frustrations with various HDR programs and the final product. You must have had one of the better days of the conference from what I had heard.   Posted: 10/31/2019 23:58:52