Tom McCreary, APSA, MPSA  


My cold friend by Tom McCreary, APSA, MPSA

December 2020 - My cold friend

December 2020 - Tom McCreary, APSA, MPSA

Original

December 2020 - Tom McCreary, APSA, MPSA

Original 2

About the Image(s)

This was taken on October 27 this year. The second of 3 days of the most destructive and earliest ice storms in the state history. It would have been a bad ice storm at any time of the year but was especially bad because it was very early in the winter and the leaves were still on the trees. Lot more surface area for the ice to collect on and bring the trees down. The older neighborhoods have large trees and above ground power lines. Of course, the ice caused the trees and tree branches to fall on the power lines and bring them down. At one time, they said that 2/3rds of the people in Oklahoma City were without electricity. I live in a duplex in an over 55 community that is about 4 years old and
has buried power lines and smaller trees. I did lose power 2 different times for about 2 days total When up to 2 inches of ice took down some major powerlines in the area were taken down. I saw several small birds flying around and landing in the trees behind my duplex. I got out my
Nikon D500 and a Tamron 100-400mm lens and took some photos of them out the window. It was raining and dark and the image was taken at 1/2000th second, f6.3, ISO 1600. The camera was on a tripod. I used Topaz Denoise to get rid of some of the noise, added a catch light to the eye, used levels to add more contrast and reversed the image. I used B&W because the image was almost monochrome as it was.


This round’s discussion is now closed!
9 comments posted




 
Wow, looks like a heck of a storm. Yet the bird looks to be doing just fine. I like that you rotated the image, somehow looking to the left seems more natural. Catch light is a nice add. You might lighten the background a little to increase the contrast of the subject. I like this image a lot.   Posted: 12/01/2020 20:04:26
Comment Image



Stephen Levitas   Stephen Levitas
I think Russ has a good idea with the background.

I have a question about flipping. So often we flip just the other way--why does this flip work?

Great story about the terrible ice storm. I love to travel the world with all of you through these stories, both good and bad. It reminds me of the Great Ice Storm of 1998 in Eastern Canada; here is the Wikipedia link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/January_1998_North_American_ice_storm#:~:text=The%20North%20American%20Ice%20Storm,and%20bordering%20areas%20from%20northern
  Posted: 12/01/2020 23:36:54
 
I am not sure why this flip works for me. But for some reason it just seems like the tree should be on the left with the branch going to the right with the bird on the right looking left. Tough for me to describe why, but it just seems more natural...   Posted: 12/02/2020 00:04:10
Tom McCreary   Tom McCreary
We Westerners read from left to right (in the Orient they read from right to left). The same reason that most of our portraits are facing to the left. Flipping puts the bird into the upper right, in a power point.   Posted: 12/05/2020 12:57:14
 
I was driving from Montreal towards the US border a bit later that winter - it was an unbelievable sight. Even some of those massive strong steel power masts had fallen down.

I fully agree that Russ's lighter version improves the image quite a lot.
As to your question about flipping an image, Stephen - interesting question. I feel that some times it is easy to decide whether an image is more "natural" seen from the opposite side. But, for me, I have not seen any rule that makes it easy for me to decide whether to flip or not. Tom's image of the bird looks just as natural seen from the original side. In fact, I like the bird looking to the right, better. And Tom, to your comment on portraits - I briefly looked through some of my favorite portraits: It seems to be a mix of which way the person is facing. Many of them facing right. Could be a coincidence, of course. I am by no means an expert.
As to reading from right to left - In Arabic, Hebrew and some Central Asia languages, they do - while in the rest of Asia, including India, China, Japan they all read horizontal from left to right. In the old days, Chinese and Japanese read vertical from top to bottom, from right to left. But that's long time ago.
I guess it comes down to each individual's preferences, and what we feel pleases the eye the most... Interesting.
  Posted: 12/07/2020 10:25:39



Diana Magor   Diana Magor
Here I am going to be different. I like the colour version with just that hint of red on the bird. It seems to make the whole just that little bit colder looking. We've never had this sort of ice storm so seeing the pictures is wonderful and also wonderfully glad I wasn't living there! The tree is fantastic so I hope you've got a million other pictures as well.
Rules for portraits are there to be broken! Sometimes it works LtoR and sometimes it's better RtoL. Go for what pleases you and hope others agree.   Posted: 12/11/2020 09:28:30



Jennifer Doerrie   Jennifer Doerrie
Wow, I really don't miss those terrible ice storms! I am amazed a bird even managed to land on the tree limb with all that ice. I think the ice adds to the interest, and agree that flipping the image works well here. However, the overall image appears dark on my monitor, which is not surprising for the weather conditions you described. I tried brightening it by adjusting the levels and also adjusting the contrast of the bird individually. Does that work, or does my adjustment take away too much of the feeling of the cold, stormy conditions?   Posted: 12/12/2020 23:40:40
Comment Image
Stephen Levitas   Stephen Levitas
I like what you did here. There is still a good tonal range, and everything is clear. The ice looks better in this version.   Posted: 12/14/2020 13:53:07



 
This is why people have bird feeders in the winter, although this little guy does look well fed. I don't miss the ice storms either, with broken trees and the danger to those below when the ice began to slide off buildings. I like the image a bit brighter to show off the crystal component of the ice. The bird does have a nice hint of color, but the contrast has been brought out in both Jennifer's and Russ's images. Either way, this was a good capture in that type of weather.   Posted: 12/22/2020 08:22:59